Sell on Instagram or Facebook – which platform will make your business a rocket, and which will just be a waste of time?

Hey friends!

Hey friends! Today, let's talk straight to the heart: Facebook Shop or Instagram Shop? Do you need both, or is one enough? What is the 5-3-1 rule? Why did Instagram Shop fail? Let's keep everything open – a scene like a home meeting, with humor, but 100% truth!

1. Facebook Shop – Old Friends, Big Reach

Plus Points

• 2.9 billion monthly users – meaning your mom, uncle, school friends are all here. People aged 25–55 are more active → Jewelry, home decor, kitchen gadgets, and courses are sold here like hot jalebi.

• Facebook Marketplace and Groups provide free traffic – post one post and 1,000 people see it.

• Checkout on Facebook (in US/UK) – customers place orders without visiting the site.

Minus Points

• Organic reach has died down – 2% of people see your post, run ads for the rest.

• Younger audiences (18–30) now only come to Facebook to wish birthdays.

Real Example: An aunty selling handmade candles made approximately $10,000/month from Facebook Groups and Shop – zero ads!

2. Instagram Shop – New Crush, Visual Magic

Plus Points

• 2 billion+ users, but those aged 18–34 dominate → A paradise of fashion, beauty, fitness, gadgets, and jewelry.

• Reels + Stories + Shop tags = one viral video, 500 orders the same day!

• Checkout on Instagram (live in US/UK/EU) – swipe up, pay, done.

• Home of influencers and UGC – people post your products themselves.

Minus Points

• Only visual products work – don't try to sell chairs or insurance.

• The algorithm is very capricious – reaching 50,000 today, 500 tomorrow.

Real Example: A small clothing brand generated approximately $2.75 million in business in 2024 from Reels alone – zero paid ads in the first 6 months!

3. Which of the two will win in 2025?

• Fashion, beauty, lifestyle, accessories → Instagram Shop will win 100%

• Home decor, kitchen, courses, local services → Facebook Shop is still king

• Budget brands + Gen-Z → Instagram

• Premium or family-oriented → Facebook

Pro Verdict: Get both! Sync from the same catalog (Meta Commerce Manager) – upload a product once, and it will be sold in both places.

4. Did Instagram Shop fail?

The hype in 2020–2022 was so intense that people thought Amazon would die. So what happened?

• The Checkout feature was only available in the US. Other countries required a link-in-bio and cart abandonment.

• The algorithm pushed Reels, clicking the Shop tab.

• People didn't even discover the "Shop" tab.

A comeback in 2024–2025 – Checkout is now live in the UK, Germany, France, and Japan, and a direct "Add to Cart" button is now available in Reels. It wasn't a failure, it was a slow burner!

5. Instagram's Secret Weapon: 5-3-1 Rule (Game Changer!)

By following this rule to growth guaranteed:

• 5 Reels per week (mix educational + funny + product)

• 3 Stories per day (behind-the-scenes, polls, swipe-up shop)

• 1 Live per week (Q&A or product launch)

A brand followed this for 90 days → followers 8K to 85K, sales approximately $15,000 to $150,000/month!

6. Facebook vs Instagram Marketing – Where to invest money?

• Cold audience (new customer) → Facebook Ads – cheap and accurate targeting (income, life events, interests)

• Warm/Hot audience (those who have already seen) → Instagram Ads + Reels – organic conversion fire

• Retargeting → Facebook pixel is still king

• Viral potential → Instagram Reels – 10x more chance

Smart people do both: capture leads on Facebook, convert on Instagram.

7. Final Boss Decision – What should I do?

• Only one product/category → Instagram focus

• Multiple categories + older audience → Facebook Shop is a must

• Budget $625–$2,500/month ads → both platforms

• Zero budget → Instagram Reels organic + Facebook Groups

Personal Favorite Combo 2025:

Add catalog to Meta Commerce Manager → Make Instagram viral with Reels → Retargeting with Facebook ads → Keep both shops running → Double the profit!

Finally, from the heart to the heart

Friends, your content and consistency matter more than the platform. A good product, a little hard work, and a smart strategy – just these three things can make you a millionaire on either Instagram or Facebook!

Sponsored Note:

If you want to create and grow your business, website, shop, ads, branding – anything – then go to Webvalix and take your business to the next level!